Alternative Sweeteners


The challenge:

Cutting out or cutting down on refined sugar is not straightforward in the way that going dairy free or gluten free is.  In that there’s a lot of alternative sweeteners available out there, some artificial, some natural, including quite a few that are not really much better for you than table sugar.  It can be tricky choosing.

For example agave syrup, commonly used in health bars and cakes, has a very low GI (Glycaemic Index) rating – which is great, but on the downside, it’s highly processed and contains more fructose than refined sugar and as much as corn syrup.  Fructose in large quantities like this is also bad news for the body, potentially leading to insulin resistance, and other harmful effects.

delicious sugar free cake


So what do you do?

My whole hearted recommendation is that you use the sweetener of your choice sparingly.   You really don’t need much.  We’ve become accustomed to eating cakes and desserts that are super sweet.  Keep off these and your palette will change - rapidly.  You will genuinely become satisfied with less.

A useful tip

You’ll see that many of the recipes I’ve shared here use, in addition to the sweetener, spices and flavourings as a way to enhance the impression of sweetness.

Find out more

There’s quite a bit of information available out there if you want to investigate more.  Although some of it can be conflicting.  I’ve included a link in the resources section to a good website I’ve found where someone is taking the trouble to research into many of the common sweetener products available in some detail, using the same criteria for all.

Some alternative natural sweeteners I’ve used so far.

Yacon syrup

Yacon Syrup – is made from a Peruvian root vegetable.  It contains sugars that are not absorbed by the body which makes it a good option.  It has a beautiful caramel flavour. Mixed with a nut butter, it makes a gorgeous toffee gloop.  It’s a good alternative where a syrup consistency is needed.

xylitol

Xylitol – is a sugar alcohol, and is usually processed from the birch tree.  It contains no fructose and has an insignificant effect on blood sugar and insulin.  It tastes as sweet as sugar and has a slight minty aftertaste.

stevia drops

Stevia – is probably the healthiest natural sweetener available.  It comes in powder or liquid form.  It is far sweeter than sugar.  Which for me has made it a more difficult sweetener to use successfully.  Use a little too much and its sweetness leaves a cloying aftertaste.  I use it from time to time in combination with another sweetener, or fruit – using just a few drops.

Peruvian carob

Peruvian carob – is a low glycaemic ingredient, not to be confused with the dark carob used as a chocolate substitute.  This is a golden powder with a caramel flavour.  It’s a great sweetener for biscuits and cheesecake bases.

baobob

Baobob Fruit Powder – is high in vitamin C and good for the immune system.  It has a fresh citrusy taste. It’s rich in fibre which slows down the rise in blood sugar.

lucuma

Lucuma – is a superfood made from a South American peach.  It is a low glycaemic ingredient. It has a warm sweetness that make particularly good for things like nut bars and biscuits

Some other commonly used alternative sweeteners

Honey – varies a great deal in glycaemic index levels and fructose content between types of honey.  Studies comparing honey to refined sugar show it has slightly less harmful effects on metabolism that refined sugar.

Maple Syrup – is made from maple tree sap and contains a number of minerals and anti-oxidants. It
contains overall about a third less sugar than refined sugar.

Dates – are a whole fruit and contain nutrients and fibre but it is still a significant source of fructose and glucose.

Rice Syrup – has a higher glycaemic index than refined sugar and most other sweeteners.

Coconut sugar – is lower on the glycaemic index than regular sugar but is high in fructose.  It comes in granulated or syrup form.  It has a warm caramel flavour.

Agave - has a very low GI (Glycaemic Index) rating but it’s highly processed and contains more fructose than refined sugar and as much as corn syrup.

A cautionary note:  As a diabetic I choose to avoid sweeteners such as the six listed above.  I would only eat something with them in – if at all - as a rare treat. I’m not a nutritionist or a doctor, but if you have other reasons to want to avoid the harmful effects of refined sugar, I would still advise some caution and restraint with them.  

Alternative sweeteners such as honey or dates are often cited as a healthy alternative to sugar to use in recipes, quantity for quantity. Whereas natural alternative sweeteners usually contain healthy nutrients – refined sugar has none - the harm from refined sugar comes not from its lack of nutrients as such but from the quantities of the sugars it contains, ie glucose and fructose - sugars that put a strain on the body if used in large and constant measure.  Natural sweeteners in most cases contain these sugars too, some contain them in significant amounts. Better therefore, to get used to less sweetness in your sweet treats.